Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

The theory of constructed emotion doesn’t say anything about the relation of emotions to reasoning.


My read:

1. Emotion has no biological marker, which refute the idea of mechanical connection between brain (and other body parts) to emotion

2. Reasoning, by general feeling, is a mental process carried out by brain primarily, but has a seemingly much stronger connection to biological signals

3. What I was inferring from the theory of constructive emotion, is that emotion really is a form of higher level reasoning. It's higher than the typical reasoning, so that it's connection with biological signals are extenuated and more indirect

I don't remember the words of the book.

This connection between reasoning and emotion is primarily my own rudimentary idea. Can be seen as an expolation of the theory.


It seems very tenuous to me to characterize a biological process as “reasoning” only because it doesn’t map to certain biological markers. And we know that emotions are significantly influenced by processes outside the brain, in particular gut biology.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: