Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

This doesn't come as a surprise; I was able to buy 1 MILLION fake followers on Instagram. The account is still alive and well.

I've been meaning to write a blog post regarding this endeavor. But moreso, I've come to the conclusion that social media needs to have verifiable audits for their userbase; similar to how there are audits done for financials. A lot of the value of these companies IS derived from their DAU/MAU and or userbase in general (example: WhatsApp - $19 billion for their 1 billion users).



I've bought a small amount of twitter followers ($10-$20) for a meme account once. They disappeared over the course of a month or two. Checking online that's what happens with the majority of services.


I hit 1 million over a year ago and all of them are still there. Besides a few -3k drops a couple months ago, 99% are still there.

Twitter is different, they seem to have a more robust banning system in place. Instagram, not so much.


>The account is still alive and well.

You expect them to ban you based on your account gaining fake followers? Wouldn't such a policy make it very easy for any third party to get a user banned?


I assumed that someone would, at the very minimum, notice that my account went from 150 to 1,000,000 followers in less than a month, and then ban the bogus followers, as they are fairly easy to identify. That didn't happen


How much did that cost? And were you able to get any value from the fake followers?


I did this solely to collect data for a personal project I am doing. My last post (on Instagram) had 10 views, so from that standpoint, I gained nothing, however, I did learn lots of valuable insight into the realm of fake followers for which I will make a blog entry detailing my findings soon.


Revenue != Value


I intended to imply that daily/monthly active users ARE the value for many businesses. Facebook valued WhatsApp's 1 billion DAU/MAU at $19 billion despite the fact that WhatsApp was not producing any cashflow.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: